Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - heretik

Pages: 1 ... 21 22 [23] 24
331
Hyde Schools / Re: sweats numbering "literally in the hundreds"
« on: October 21, 2010, 09:31:26 PM »
Quote from: "Ursus"
Quote from: "heretik"
Quote from: "Samara"
Heretik: Just curious about the following - not in a rancorous way.
What about:
1. NDA's
2. No way out
3. Blind adherence to the weekend "program"
4. Does it use ridicule and humiliation to coerce change?
5. Does it try and force you to accept their interpretation of your reality or past events?

Can you challenge or opt out if you disagree or something just isn't jibing for you? Can you honestly the leader is not some narcissist with Guru Fantasies?
Samara, I will be back later tonight to answer. OK. Have to go for now.
See ya.
Yes yes. Better do some more fact-checking first ... with some of yer "warrior" friends who are a lil more in the know, eh?

Speaking of spin...
Quote from: "heretik"
Yes, the weekend does have a "sweat" towards the end. You are asked to bring in the burdens of others, the pain of others and to ask, "mother earth" to help you with this pain you carry for others. I at first had a hard time understanding this concept, primarily because I came to each of my first 10 sweats with so much of my own pain but as time moved and my pain subsided I began to think of others and there burdens. I wanted to help in whatever way I could, some who I loved, I wanted to carry there pain with them. I became more intimate with people and nature through these sweats (which now are literally in the hundreds).
Hundreds??!! Over what period of time? Even for, say, a period of a decade, "hundreds" translates into at least twenty per year, which is generally not the pace opted for when it comes to ruminating on "deep spiritual insights," let alone experiencing "6 hour rolfing massages" with subsequent delusions of levitation as a bonus.

That is... unless you're addicted to it! Are you SURE your electrolytes are still in balance??!   :D  Altered states can be achieved through a variety of ways and means, not necessarily dependent on the imbibing of narcotic substances...

Quote from: "heretik"
Yes, people are told about the weekend as much as you can but still you really can not explain enough to prepare one for this weekend. Like I said it is brutal.
Then you come out the other end and you feel weightless, like a 6 hour rolfing massage you levitate after your done
. Have you ever ran a marathon, biked long distance, worked incredibly long hours to get a project done, stayed up night after night with a sick baby, well then you know. Try all of this in a weekend.... :rofl: only kidding but close.

Listen I am not sure why you are acting in this manner but I see no need to talk to me like this. I did not know that my word would be subjected to such inquiry. I have no need to lie or embellish. I received a email/Pm the other night, I have noticed you are also a moderator. Let me make myself clear please, I am not this person. So please stop with the subtle sarcasm, if you have a question just ask.  
Let me explain myself a little better, my first sweat I did was at a Nordic Lodge with a Finnish family. Some people would confuse this to a steam room but in fact they were carrying out a Indian ritual, I was 14 years old, that was over 40 years ago. I said hundreds Ursus, I believe I was being moderate. It is not uncommon for people to sweat on a weekly bases, which would then put the number at 52 per year x 10 years, that would be hundreds. I have been sweating for 40 years with a average of 30 times a year, some years less then others.  
Addiction to sweating well if this is how you choose to see it, I would say fine. I could find more destructive venues to be hung up on.

332
Hyde Schools / Re: HAPA -- an LGAT
« on: October 21, 2010, 04:21:49 PM »
Quote from: "Samara"
Heretik: Just curious about the following - not in a rancorous way.
What about:
1. NDA's
2. No way out
3. Blind adherence to the weekend "program"
4. Does it use ridicule and humiliation to coerce change?
5. Does it try and force you to accept their interpretation of your reality or past events?

Can you challenge or opt out if you disagree or something just isn't jibing for you? Can you honestly the leader is not some narcissist with Guru Fantasies?

Samara, I will be back later tonight to answer. OK. Have to go for now.
See ya.

333
Feed Your Head / Re: The New Macho!!!
« on: October 21, 2010, 04:17:43 PM »
Quote from: "Ursus"
Quote from: "heretik"
I believe this was intended for insight and maybe testimony. I am sorry it has incited so much rancor amongst the few.
Really? Since you've seen fit to quote that post, once again, for the fourth time, in what was then a seven-post thread... I'd suggest that "inciting rancor" might, in fact, be amongst your goals here.  :D

I do apologize if my duplicity in posting has offended you but by no means is their a alternative motive here. I am knew to this posting thing here.
I did read over my posts and I cracked up a bit, I could see what you were referring to. :)
I hope as you get to know me your comments in red above will have proved to be unnecessary.

I felt this was a great post and a commitment for men to see. The post was meant to be inspiring.

334
Hyde Schools / Re: HAPA -- an LGAT
« on: October 21, 2010, 04:03:28 PM »
Quote from: "Anne Bonney"
Quote from: "heretik"

The "WE" was a statement for you and I. Meaning why would Anne and heretik want these workshops going on. No I am not  a employee. I know several people that would be very interested in your comments you made here today.
I was wondering if I could get the information I asked for, Anne.

Being blessed with an amazing husband is wonderful, Salute!! as I think you know is not the rule but the exception. Men want to change that, more and more men are saying every day, how can I be a better husband, Dad, friend ect....

I'll try and find out what you're asking for.  Some of the conversations were online and two of them just kinda happened when I was out having drinks with a few friends.  Some guy brought it up and we started talking about it, but I don't recall where these workshops (that might not even be the correct term, more so my lack of a better one but it did include the sweatlodge thing) took place, or if the guy even mentioned it.

Thank you Anne. I have noticed your posts in other threads especially the thread concerning "compliance", you write a compelling story. (I know off topic, just wanted to say.)
Back to the topic and your response. Yes, the weekend does have a "sweat" towards the end. You are asked to bring in the burdens of others, the pain of others and to ask, "mother earth" to help you with this pain you carry for others. I at first had a hard time understanding this concept, primarily because I came to each of my first 10 sweats with so much of my own pain but as time moved and my pain subsided I began to think of others and there burdens. I wanted to help in whatever way I could, some who I loved, I wanted to carry there pain with them. I became more intimate with people and nature through these sweats (which now are literally in the hundreds).
I know this probably sounds weird Anne but this worked for me. Sitting in some Psychiatrist's office just wasn't working for me, I needed to be connected holistically. The natural earth made this possible for me.
Large Group Awarness Therapy can be therapeutic in so far as serving to restore good health, being healthy and promoting recovery from unhappiness. This would be the LGAT's I have encountered in workshops I support. Yes MKP does have aggressive in your face LGAT's, I am not interested in those particularly. They just don't appeal to me because of my past issues, so I would not ascribe to them but I also can't say they don't work for others. They do, I have witnessed this.

Till later.

335
Hyde Schools / Re: HAPA -- an LGAT
« on: October 20, 2010, 09:03:12 PM »
Quote from: "Samara"
I was being irreverent about the naked stuff. I don't care about all that.

I was referring to the article by Mitchelson.  The NDA's and psychodramas.  The fact that a group would require secrecy raises red flags for the obvious reasons. I have not been a member of this group. To be honest, I'm not a group membership kind of gal. (Although I really should sign up for Costco.)  I've simply never subscribed to any  set ideology and tend to prefer direct, no BS experiences over LGAT experentials. I just know I would not participate in anything that required me to give up autonomy, subscribe to group think, unchallenged,  sign NDA's and forfeit my own safe mode of communication.  I also could never follow blindly  some guru-leader.  

But, if you received something of value from MK, by all means, share. I don't know much about it.

Hey, thanks for commenting. I am new to this so by all means if I ask to many questions tell me. I am not afraid to answer questions myself. MK, is and was for me a educational experience, I was stuck in a big way and that weekend help with that. There was maybe 45 men of which I knew personally (5), knew off (15) and the rest were friends or close acquaintances of everyone. So it was a close intimate weekend. I know for a fact that is not the experience 95% have.
I will comment more on this tomorrow, I am tired and have a throbbing headache.
take care...

336
Thought Reform / Re: Training, Therapy or Thought Reform in the TTI?
« on: October 20, 2010, 08:41:12 PM »
Quote from: "psy"
Quote from: "heretik"
So back to my point they are either extremely uneducated, in denial/delusional or they believe what they are doing/practicing is working.

All of the above.  Usually the program owners/directors are clued in to the fact that it's basically a scam, but even some of those were once staff and simply believe they have the one true way to help kids.  As to how they can implement such elaborate tactics without knowing what they're doing?  They learned from predecessors who designed the system.  Most programs today are basically cult copycats.  They might not have designed (or even understand) the thought reform system/processes, but they implement what they were taught and from their perspective, it "works".  It does provide dramatic results while the participant is in the program.  It's a dramatic illusion for the staff as well.

I got caught up in Awakes answer to this other poster that I neglected to respond to your comments. Not that I'm sure you were holding your breath. :)
Thanks for your direct summation of what I was driving at here. It can be very confusing for someone not educated on treatment programs to understand the elaborate processes of a everyday program.
I wonder if the employees were trained properly and had experience would these thought reform processes still provide a viable education for the participant. Does thought reform work, is it a suitable model, can we expect positive results if instituted properly.
A question here that has crossed my mind, it goes along with the comment I made concerning work environments, is there not thought reform happening in practically all work,educational and family settings to a greater or lesser degree.
I am not bringing this up to rationalize the atrocities going on in programs people here have talked about, just trying to understand how it all transpires.
I have heard words spoke here concerning re-education, thought reform and others I can't remember right now and I am trying to understand.
I am reading more and I have to say that sitting in a chair or standing in front of a room is a hell of a way to be re-educated. Not very subtle. I get this type of overt thought reform also to include the violent yelling at one another during groups and the emasculation you received by your peers while experiencing a "haircut".
I want to get at the more subtle reformation of the mind that went on/goes on in a program. How is this happening.

337
Hyde Schools / Re: HAPA -- an LGAT
« on: October 20, 2010, 07:26:57 PM »
Quote from: "Samara"
Uh, Heretik, I don't care if people want to hang out naked. My post is not remotely anti-nudity.  !!!! ???? You are really making a mountain out of a molehill here.

I simply said "buyer beware about group psychodynamics." Big Deal.

And another thing: Who were you before Heretik, because I have a feeling this is a new name, same shit scenario.

Nope! I have no idea what your talking about here with this last comment or why it was even necessary. Yes, I have known a couple of people who have posted here but what does that have to do with me. As far as I know they are gone, I am here.
I hope we can have mutual respect for one another, I see that is not always at a premium here.

I would rather talk about the topic. You mentioned group dynamics which is a interesting subject. Would you please elaborate more on this (in so far as it deals with the MKP weekend workshop) when you have a chance.
If by chance you have not the knowledge concerning the MKP weekend can you just elaborate anyway on what you may be able to gather is going on.
Anne and yourself have made several comments in your recent posts and it has sparked questions for me. This is why I wrote about my concerns for your comments about men nudity.

Thanks, nice talking with you Samara.

338
Feed Your Head / Re: The New Macho!!!
« on: October 20, 2010, 04:14:22 PM »
Quote from: "Samara"
heretik: it wasn't done tongue in cheek or even hilariously. It was coupled with barrages of humilations, badgering, and screaming.

I am not sure where everyone is taking this posting. What I would suggest is just accept the post as it was intended and stop analyzing the beJesus out of it. Sigh.....

339
Spiritual Narcissism...nifty little catch phrase word. Very fad coming from seasoned work shop junkies covering the circuit. One thing you must understand 90% of these people posting negative comments will be in another workshop within the year. They are addicted to them, they bring structure and organization to there lives. They want James Ray and others to be where they are. Cause and effect, leaders and followers and life goes on.
Yes Anne these people want their Gurus and when one fails and is cast aside they find another to replace them and life goes on.

340
Feed Your Head / Re: The New Macho!!!
« on: October 19, 2010, 05:34:21 PM »
Quote from: "bobbyfischer"
Quote
He takes responsibility for himself and is also willing to be his brother's keeper.

http://www.secretprisonsforteens.dk/for ... r_propheet

The Brothers Keeper propheet

Lugs:  Part of the ice breaker in the Brother's Keeper propheet. A student is required to come up with a short performance that makes fun of themselves, and act it out for the entire peer group. This is done repeatedly, since every time a new member of the peer group comes up with and performs their "lug", all of the previous students who have already come up with theirs have to do it again. (Similar structure to the "12 days of Christmas" song.) It could also simply mean the act of a staff member imitating you and making fun of how you behave.  

The Circle: An exercise in the brother's keeper propheet. Two students are singled out from the rest of the peer group. These students are normally the omegas of the group, (i.e. the bottom of the pecking order) and as such, command the least respect. The rest of the peer group is instructed to close ranks and form a circle, with everyone facing inside and linking arms. The two ostracized students are then required to try to break into the circle any way they can, while the rest of the peer group has to try to keep them from getting inside. The purpose was to provide a metaphor for 1. How you keep people on the outside every day. and

2. How you keep yourself on the outside every day.  

Turning your back:  An exercise from the brother's keeper. Students are paired up and take turns turning their back on each other.  

Pushing away  An exercise from the brother's keeper. Students are paired up and take turns shoving each other. The exercise was supposed to signify how you push people away every day.


All this means is to love and care for your brother. This is not a LGAT/Propheet. If it takes performing a Propheet or LGAT to love and care for your brother, well I hope you succeed.

341
Hyde Schools / Re: HAPA -- an LGAT
« on: October 19, 2010, 05:30:00 PM »
duplicate.

342
Hyde Schools / Re: HAPA -- an LGAT
« on: October 19, 2010, 05:23:27 PM »
Quote from: "Samara"
I've been through lots of things and you know what? What it comes down to is pretty simple. People fight the simple.  If you are alone and not responsible for anyone but yourself, just live your life how you see fit and don't hurt anyone. You can be free AND responsible and honest.  If you are responsible for others, it is more work. It can be a struggle sometimes.  Accept it and grow the fuck up.

People know what they should be doing; they just don't want to admit it. Because then you have to step up to the plate.

And, again: Why would a program need NDA's and encounter groups? No "support" group should require an NDA. (Non disclosure agreement)

But as I've said: I don't care what consenting adults do as long as they "first, do no harm." But obviously, some of these groups are scams.  It's not terrible for unfulfilled men to have access to the pros and the cons before they drop their bucks and possibly their dignity along with their clothing.  If it turns out great, and the bad reviews are unfounded, then no harm, no foul. But it is good to be have information and a few quick tips in case your weekend veers toward the cautionary tales.

Just like you'd look up reviews for a car, an appliance, or a trip.

I see you did not want to answer the questions. Alright you don't have to. I think you see what I mean though, concerning men.
Why are men dropping their clothing, why is being naked such a issue here, are you not comfortable in your nakedness. Do you not find your disrobed body beautiful. There is no shame attached to being naked unless you place it there. It does not really make a difference what society/western culture has taught you. To much American culture is tied to the body (the look, appeal ect..) it is shallow.
Why are we having a issue with adult consenting men inviting in new challenges. There is more information about the weekend then is being let on here. Men are not going into this weekend blind, without a level of knowledge concerning what they may face.
One other point. I am puzzled by the similarities being placed on MKP by the three of you. I know the three of you have first hand knowledge of programs, especially the ones you attended. Yet I have not read where any of you have ever attended a workshop for men or the equivalent for women. Now, from reading your prior posts I am under the assumption that because you went through a program and maybe some of the exercises preformed at the workshop resemble your LGAT's or group encounters, you have a unique perception. Ursus has tied Hyde School into MKP and has made a determination that this has influence over Hyde School in some way. I am not sure your perception is accurate, we are adults, most of us are of ages around 40-50, with a small percentage in their late 20's and 30's.
I can understand the anger coming from men after the workshop, especially the men that had a ruff time and really felt MKP was not for them. The weekend workshop, I will not lie is one tough in your face constantly demanding weekend. Yes, people are told about the weekend as much as you can but still you really can not explain enough to prepare one for this weekend. Like I said it is brutal.
Then you come out the other end and you feel weightless, like a 6 hour rolfing massage you levitate after your done. Have you ever ran a marathon, biked long distance, worked incredibly long hours to get a project done, stayed up night after night with a sick baby, well then you know. Try all of this in a weekend.... :rofl:  only kidding but close.
Just think guys if you had never been introduced to any kind of dynamic like this before in your life, at least you three have the benefit of experiencing something close but it is not close enough. In this case you have a choice go further or stop, yes there are people pushing you, that is part of life but for once in their life for many men they experince their limits. It is awesome.
I'll get back.

343
Hyde Schools / Re: HAPA -- an LGAT
« on: October 19, 2010, 03:30:05 PM »
Quote from: "Samara"
But why do men need a program to be men? Why would a program need NDA's and encounter groups? Why not BBQ, have a beer, watch a game, pay your bills, be generally honest and responsible, appreciate your S.O, communicate respectfully and fuck happily? It's not really that hard.

First let me ask you a few questions.
1. have kids
2. married
3. divorced
4. never married but have kids
5. was father of kids a decent man to his children.
6.  was he a good man to you.

 your answers should tell you, Samara. If it wasn't that hard everyone would be doing it.

344
Feed Your Head / Re: The New Macho!!!
« on: October 19, 2010, 03:16:08 PM »
Quote from: "heretik"
The New Macho

He cleans up after himself.
He cleans up the planet.
He is a role model for young men.
He is rigorously honest and fiercely optimistic.

He holds himself accountable.
He knows what he feels.
He knows how to cry and he lets it go.
He knows how to rage without hurting others.
He knows how to fear and how to keep moving.
He seeks self-mastery.

He's let go of childish shame.
He feels guilty when he's done something wrong.
He is kind to men, kind to women, kind to children.
He teaches others how to be kind.
He says he's sorry.

He stopped blaming women or his parents or men for his pain years ago.
He stopped letting his defenses ruin his relationships.
He stopped letting his penis run his life.
He has enough self respect to tell the truth.
He creates intimacy and trust with his actions.
He has men that he trusts and that he turns to for support.
He knows how to roll with it.
He knows how to make it happen.
He is disciplined when he needs to be.
He is flexible when he needs to be.
He knows how to listen from the core of his being.

He's not afraid to get dirty.
He's ready to confront his own limitations.
He has high expectations for himself and for those he connects with.
He looks for ways to serve others.
He knows he is an individual.
He knows that we are all one.
He knows he is an animal and a part of nature.
He knows his spirit and his connection to something greater.

He knows that the future generations are watching his actions.
He builds communities where people are respected and valued.
He takes responsibility for himself and is also willing to be his brother's keeper.

He knows his higher purpose.
He loves with fierceness.
He laughs with abandon, because he gets the joke.

This is the Mature Masculine - it is the redefinition of masculinity for the 21st century. By no means is this list complete. You are welcome to come and add your gifts to this community. - Boysen Hodgson

I believe this was intended for insight and maybe testimony. I am sorry it has incited so much rancor amongst the few.

345
Hyde Schools / Re: HAPA -- an LGAT
« on: October 19, 2010, 03:11:09 PM »
Quote from: "Anne Bonney"
Quote from: "heretik"
Quote from: "Anne Bonney"
Quote from: "heretik"
There are many stories about MKP, most when viewed from the outside look very weird. Why are men (as you say here, Samara and Anne) running around naked and bashing fictitious womens heads with clubs. :) I can only say we are not.
I will say this in short, far to long have men been absent from their duties, we became lost. This is one way to regain the footing we gave up and be the men we are supposed to be.
I have found women (a true woman) find me more attractive in a innate way.  

All I can tell you is that the 1/2 dozen or so guys I've spoken with that have attended these "workshops" have had nothing but bad things to say about it.  They said it felt very cult-like and that there was a ton of women bashing in them.  They said it seemed like the leader(s) had some bad experiences with women and didn't know how to deal with it other than to blame society and proclaim that women had "stolen their masculinity".  And that they're very, very angry about the ERA and see it as the beginning of the downfall of their (men's) reign.

Well then, I would say to you keep your men far away from MKP, especially from the state that your speaking from and all other states. Because they are definitely experiencing a workshop that is not healthy. Very sad to hear this. I would like to get the workshops they attended please, not names, just the workshop. The state and maybe the town, that should be enough. Why would we want these workshops to continue in these places if the entire workshop has gone off in another direction not intended by MKP.

Are you affiliated with MKP?


Quote
Thanks Anne, for pointing this out. Please help me to gather this information, if you would. PM me if you would like with the information.
Men will always have their issues with women as women with men. What has not been healthy for so long is the reactions men have to the problems. The focus in my opinion should stay with me if I am troubled, especially if I do not know what is disturbance within me. Women find communicating with men much more advantageous if we are able to collectively broker the problems. (so to speak)
Thanks


I dunno.....I've been blessed with an amazing husband.  He can be annoying sometimes, but communication isn't really a problem between us.  He's put up with me being a raging lunatic when I was first learning about what Straight did to me and he was more patient and understanding than I could ever ask for.


The "WE" was a statement for you and I. Meaning why would Anne and heretik want these workshops going on. No I am not  a employee. I know several people that would be very interested in your comments you made here today.
I was wondering if I could get the information I asked for, Anne.

Being blessed with an amazing husband is wonderful, Salute!! as I think you know is not the rule but the exception. Men want to change that, more and more men are saying every day, how can I be a better husband, Dad, friend ect....

Pages: 1 ... 21 22 [23] 24