Perri, I see now that it was Amanda that said that about the drugs and jail. And I agree it's unfair to compare anyone to Ghandi or Mother Theresa. For one thing, none of us meet that standard. For another, word has it that even they never fully lived up to their celebrity images. And, certainly, nobody who's arguing w/ you does either.
But I still think it's unlikely that you would view teenagers the same way if you hadn't been through the Program. And my guess is that you might have been better off facing the actual consequences for whatever you did to harm someone than dodging that for 'treatment' by WWASP.
And that really is a very important issue these days. There's a huge movement in public policy to provide this same form of 'treatment' to people convicted of various statutory and even real crimes. I think it's a hoodwink. I think a whole lot of people plead out and take the mandatory treatment thinking it's better than jail. But what actually happens is that they have a PO looking over their shoulder and, often times, they wind up w/ more serious charges than the original issue, more jail time and other obligations than they would have had
and an added mindfuck on top of it all.
Amanda, you're absolutely right. Most kids engage in excessive behavior at some point. And most kids learn self control; sometimes through some hard knocks, others by observation. But, at least in my generation, very few actually swear off of all illicit drug use. I know people who will smoke a join if you offer AND it's not a high risk situation (they're not about to drive, it's a private place, ect.) And I even know people who will still, even at age 40, cop some coke for a special occasion. But those ones are few and far between. Most ppl I know who did coke as teenagers found it either unmanagable or just unpleasant and just put it down pretty quickly.
But very, very few people actually get busted. Even if they do, most just pay a fine anyway, unless they commit a contempt of cop violation or make some obvious mistake like trying to make a living at it or getting too involved w/ those who do.
Personally, I'm very conflicted about that. Most of the people I knew as a young woman who were trying to turn a buck at drug dealing were otherwise decent people. So when my kids' friends decide to try their hand at that (if I find out about it, anyway), I do my best to explain how the game is rigged and why it'll never pay off. I wouldn't want my kids to be the kind of people who cut good people out of their lives just because they do a few foolish things. But, at the same time, I don't want my kids getting dragged into untold drama, either. It's realy a dicey situation.
At the bottom of it, most kids seem to understand very well that the law is wrong, even though the intentions behind it are on the mark. But they have a hard time seperating the natural consequences of their own behavior from the contrived consequences put on them. Is it fair that one kid skates by till they're mature enough to get serious about life while another gets busted, gets a conviction, loses their drivers license education funding, etc. and is set back by all that by the time they mature that much?
I don't think it's fair at all. And I certainly think it's a dirty trick to "treat" kids for bucking unjust laws. Someone introduced Ghandi into this discussion. Well Ghandi was a rebel, an outlaw. He broke unjust laws and encouraged others to do the same. The most famous act of mass civil disobedience that he organized was the freelance making and selling of salt. Under our laws, it's OK to go to a shrink and get permission to purchase Xanex from the pharma co's(which is the most popular legal drug among ppl who find cannabis to be therapeutic) But it's illegal to bypass the pharma monopoly by growing a plant either for personal use or for profit. What's the diff? I can't say these kids are wrong in what they're doing on ethical grounds. And I
hate telling them to suck it up; it's just demoralizing. So what's an old broad to do?
The disrespect for the possession laws fosters a disrespect for laws and the system in general... On top of this is the distinct impression among the youth that some police may use the marihuana laws to arrest people they don't like for other reasons, whether it be their politics, their hair style or their ethnic background.
http://www.druglibrary.org/schaffer/library/studies/nc/ncmenu.htm' target='_new'>Marihuana: A Signal of Misunderstanding