Split from ASR: Private School or RTC

[TheWho]

So, DJ,  we established you would seek outside help for your family if they had a problem you couldnt solve.....thats what we did.

[Troll Control]

So, DJ,  we established you would seek outside help for your family if they had a problem you couldnt solve.....thats what we did.

No, we've established that I would seek outside help for a quantifiable problem that I could not solve.  You sent your kid to treatment in the absence of pathology.  I wouldn't do that.

[TheWho]

How about if your roof was leaking and you couldnt fix it yourself and your famiy was getting sick from all the moisture and mold, would you let them suffer or seek outside help?  or would you wait for them to be diagnosed with something?

[RobertBruce]

You're dodging the question.


What was wrong with your daughter that you felt you had to send her away?

Very simple question. In all of your subsequent analogies you keep using identifiable problems that can be solved by a specialist.

[Troll Control]

How about if your roof was leaking and you couldnt fix it yourself and your famiy was getting sick from all the moisture and mold, would you let them suffer or seek outside help?  or would you wait for them to be diagnosed with something?

Leaky roof, mold...They're quantifiable.

"How much water is leaking in?"...  "Three gallons per hour."

"How much mold is there?"...  "A LOT.  It's covering 140 square feet of wall and floor."

These questions have quantifiable answers.  

What was the quantifiable reason you sent your kid to a residential treatment center?

[TheWho]

How about if your roof was leaking and you couldnt fix it yourself and your famiy was getting sick from all the moisture and mold, would you let them suffer or seek outside help?  or would you wait for them to be diagnosed with something?

Leaky roof, mold...They're quantifiable.

"How much water is leaking in?"...  "Three gallons per hour."

"How much mold is there?"...  "A LOT.  It's covering 140 square feet of wall and floor."

These questions have quantifiable answers.  

What was the quantifiable reason you sent your kid to a residential treatment center?

So by not answering directly  it sounds like you would seek outside help...that is what I did !!  you may chose not to if it happened to your family and that is your choice, DJ

My point !!

[RobertBruce]

You're still dodging.

What was wrong with your daughter that you felt you needed to ship her off?

Specifically what was the problem?


This isn't that difficult. When you get done either answering the question or dodging it repeatedly I did repond to your last post to me. If you feel like working on those questions they'll be there waiting for you.

[Troll Control]

How about if your roof was leaking and you couldnt fix it yourself and your famiy was getting sick from all the moisture and mold, would you let them suffer or seek outside help?  or would you wait for them to be diagnosed with something?

Leaky roof, mold...They're quantifiable.

"How much water is leaking in?"...  "Three gallons per hour."

"How much mold is there?"...  "A LOT.  It's covering 140 square feet of wall and floor."

These questions have quantifiable answers.  

What was the quantifiable reason you sent your kid to a residential treatment center?

So by not answering directly  it sounds like you would seek outside help...that is what I did !!  you may chose not to if it happened to your family and that is your choice, DJ

My point !!

Boy, you're pretty dense today, Whooter.  Are you high on something that interferes with your ability to read?

What is the quantifiable reason you sent your kid to a residential treatment center?  Simple question.

While you're at it though, what must your daughter do for you in order for you to love her?

Never answered that one either...

Again, this is why nobody respects your opinion, Who.  You will never answer with a straight answer, you just avoid anything you don't want to answer.  At this point you look dumber for avoiding the question than you do for your original statement that you only love your daughter when she meets certain conditions.

[Troll Control]

Specifically what was the problem?

This is where you run into the problem with Whooter.

There is nothing specifically wrong with his kid.  Just some unquantifiable mumbo-jumbo about how Whooter felt about her.

He's still at the stage where he keeps reporting "she was off-track," but cannot name a single specific about what that means (he has mentioned truancy, but denied this was the precipitant cause of the "placement").  

In reality, "off-track" means "makes daddy frustrated."

[TheWho]

Here you go assuming again, DJ,, stick to the facts.  That is what got you all riled up to begin with when you got caught assuming

.  The real reason DJ is mad is he clams he called George Millers office about a bill and they told him the bill was dead and it was the republicans fault.

I provided links which proved he never made the call and made it all up.  The bill is in subcommittee and is being rewritten.

Here take another look:

http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bill.xpd?bill=h109-1738


http://tinyurl.com/3ah7le

So we will have to endure his personal attacks until he gets over it, sorry folks.

[Troll Control]

Here you go assuming again, DJ,, stick to the facts.  That is what got you all riled up to begin with when you got caught assuming

.  The real reason DJ is mad is he clams he called George Millers office about a bill and they told him the bill was dead and it was the republicans fault.

I provided links which proved he never made the call and made it all up.  The bill is in subcommittee and is being rewritten.

Here take another look:

http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bill.xpd?bill=h109-1738


http://tinyurl.com/3ah7le

So we will have to endure his personal attacks until he gets over it, sorry folks.

WTF are you talking about?

I read your links and they say the bill is stalled, as we all know it is already.  What does that prove?  This is old news.  All I said is that when I talked to Rep. Miller's office, they explained the bill was killed in committee, as is evidenced by the fact that it never came up for debate.

I never said you were wrong, nor did you prove anything.

Now...  You made a statement earlier that you don't always love your daughter.   What does she have to do in order for you to love her?

[Troll Control]

You made the statement, so explain it.  I don't see the big deal.  It's your statement, you said it, you believe it and I only want to know the details.  

How is asking you a question about what you said a personal attack?  YOU said it, not me.

[/b]What does she have to do in order for you to love her?

[TheWho]

I read your links and they say the bill is stalled, as we all know it is already.

Thank you DJ, now that wasnt too hard was it?

[Troll Control]

Well, sounds like an impasse, I was just curious about this:

And I am interested in how DJ feels he can expect his kids to love him unconditionally, even if he ignores them for long periods of time?just curious on who taught him this is a good thing.

But I can let it go, lets get back to the topic and stop wasting space.

DJ doesn't expect unconditional love, as DJ has stated over and over.

Whooter only loves his daughter based on certain conditions and won't explain those conditions.  

Whooter keeps misquoting DJ even though DJ dutifully reposts his original statement like this:

Dysfunction Junction wrote:


I don't take anyone else's love for granted, but I do love my own familiy unconditionally and would without hesitation sacrifice my own life for any one of theirs.

I don't take anyone else's love for granted
I don't take anyone else's love for granted
I don't take anyone else's love for granted
I don't take anyone else's love for granted
I don't take anyone else's love for granted
I don't take anyone else's love for granted

Can you read it now, Whooter?

Now, what must your kid do in order for you to love her?

this sums up the who's nonsense for the day.  he keeps misquoting and saying things that nobody else said and he never answers the simple questio nof why he chooses not to love his daughter.  it's very sad to think that this poor girl was likely treated in the same manner at home that the who treats people here.  i feel bad for her, but not having someone like the who love you probably isn't that bad of a deal anyway.

oh, he did it over here, too?   :cry:

[Nihilanthic]

No more replies and the troll dies!