"Not always the case. Overprotective parents can also produce unruly kids. (Points to self.)"
_________________
I agree. Neglect and overprotection can create the same outcome. 'Under-loved' or 'over-loved', both black holes- grieving/searching for the piece(s) they weren't given, and can manifest the exact 'symptoms' with minor differences. And I use 'loved' loosely, as I've seen many a kid horrendously abused/neglected in the name of love.
When you boil it all down, it's pretty simple. Humans need to have their basic needs for survival met, feel they belong, be provided accurate information, and have modeled for them how to function in a group (family, society, world).
In that sense, you see that overprotection is a form of neglect as well. So, the curler's kid can be just as unruly as the crack whore's, or more so, depending on the factors involved.
Those who seem to fare best are the ones who somehow manage to grieve the loss (consciously or not), put it all in perspective, and give those things to themselves the best they can.
Few humans have had all their needs met, therefore can't provide them. Welcome to the human condition. We've all been, and continue to be, conditioned toward division. It's good for the economy!!! Bad for humans."
These terms like spoiled v overprotected are very amorphous so its hard to comunicate with them, but they mean different things to me. Im not sure what you mean by overprotected, but by spoiled I mean given too much positive attention (if such a thing exists)
Whereas with neglect you are not given any positive attention. -any attention period.
With neglect you are not having any basic needs met period, while with being spoiled your basic needs are all met but some of the more "supplemental" elements are lacking.
So your mother and father spend lots of time with you, are kind to you, have a freindship with you, - but if youdont want to take the garbage out, no ones stressing. With neglect there is no bond ,no one will spend time with you and no one is kind. You are alone in a wilderness.
This produces different symptoms. The Jewish American Princess and the little girl whose parents locked her in a room in for the first 8 years of her life may both seem distracted, but the Jap has the capability of engaging where as the neglected child simply has not develouped the ability. In fact, perhaps the "symptoms" are from a far distance akin, but they are evidence of diseases that are worlds apart in terminality.
Heres a blog about spoiled children...things can go wrong..but not really in the "troubled" sense.
http://64.233.161.104/search?q=cache:yE ... =clnk&cd=5