On 2004-08-28 12:01:00, shanlea wrote:
Do you have any alternatives to comp ed?
Yes, homeschool (or, more accurately, non-public alternative education) If you can hold your nose and get past the perception of homeschoolers as religious weirdos, you'll find that most of us really are not. The religious groups tend to get more media attention because 1) that's the perception so that's where journalists go looking for interviews and 2) because they tend to be better organized than us hippie drop outs by virtue of their foundation in church communities.
NEA estimates 1.1 million of us for the year 2002 - 2003. But they only count the registered hsers. They don't count duel enrolement, private umbrella 'schools' that offer the service of pumping paperwork and ensuring minimum compliance w/ education policies, nevermind underground homeschoolers who simply never report to the school district the fact that they have school aged children.
I'm starting to think Milton Friedman had the right idea (wouldn't be the first time, either) when he came up w/ school vouchers. For all the possibly problems w/ that plan, it would at least fuck
up the current power and control structure that exists. That, imo, can not be a bad thing!
But I don't think you were asking how to kill the beast, but how to
replace the beast. My simple, unbelievable and radically counterintitive answer is don't replace the beast! Before compulsory education (starting, in this country, in the mid 1800 at gunpoint in Massachusetts) more American were functionally litterate than today (per capita) Americans read more newspapers, voted more often, ran their own farms and other businesses and created their own prosperity w/ incredible success unprecidented in all of human history.
Just make sure your own kids can read, write and do basic math and that they understand completely that everything else is their responsibility. Sure, you and other kind adults will give them help, training and encouragement if they ask. But no one can teach you how to be an independent minded, competent adult. You have to teach yourself that.
It will be generally found that those who sneer habitually at human nature and affect to despise it, are among its worst and least pleasant examples
--Charles Dickens
_________________
Ginger Warbis ~ Antigen
Seed sibling `71 - `80
Straight South (Sarasota, FL)
10/80 - 10/82
Anonymity AnonymousSome days, it's just not worth chewing through the leather straps.