Treatment Abuse, Behavior Modification, Thought Reform > The Troubled Teen Industry

Positive Impact??

<< < (9/14) > >>

Anonymous:

--- Quote ---On 2004-04-28 07:20:00, Anonymous wrote:

"Greg, that is just it, you don't have all of the facts on Spots and the gang.  All you know is what they post publically.  What they do privately behind the scenes, is what you and all readers on this public forum do not know."

--- End quote ---


And You do have the facts, is that it?
You are all knowing and all seeing, and have it All figured  out, huh?
What Spots and the gang (gotta love that Spots!)is doing behind the scenes is something you are an authority on?
And it must be something Real Bad, huh?
What oh What could it be?

cherish wisdom:
by Sandra Kidd, Educational Consultant
June, 1999
Austin, Texas
512-338-1272

A beautiful beachfront Mexican villa located on the Sea of Cortez in a quaint fishing village and American retirement community called Bahia de Kino is the location for Positive Impact, a new residential specialty program for adolescent boys between the ages of 12 to 18. Here the boys work and live as a ?community of family? while learning new cognitive thinking and positive behavioral patterns through mentoring and leadership development. The average length of stay is from six to eighteen months and thanks to the Mexican economy the program is more affordable to some parents.

A profile of an appropriate candidate is a boy who has one or more of the following situations: a sense of adventure though often misguided and overly risky, substance abuse, a belief that parents and other authority figures are dispensable, suffers from loss of a Father-figure or needs male mentoring, needs life skill development, has a sense of entitlement, underachieves in school, is unable to make positive choices, or is involved in a negative peer subculture. The directors of the program believe that removing the boys from their natural, familiar environments forces them to have an ?imbalance,? and their exposure to a new, foreign culture makes them receptive to change and reflection, which then ?creates balance? within their lives.

A team of professionals called life coaches guides this process. Even though Positive Impact is a new program, the professionals who are involved in the program each have many years of experience working with troubled youth. They clearly know how to facilitate changes in attitudes and behaviors. This team includes J. John Anderson, M.S., Executive Director, Keith A. Breiland, M.D., Medical Director, Michael Cumming, M.S., Program Director, and Craig Rogers, Residential Living Coordinator.

I observed a GGI (Guided Group Interaction) that was led by Mike and Craig and was impressed with the genuine interest and concern they had for the boys in counseling them. They were good at recognizing destructive thinking and behavior that had become patterns for them, and helping them restructure their approach to positive, solution-focused living and coping skills. This process of counseling is called ?Positive Peer Environment.? It teaches the boys how to: identify problems, accept responsibility for their actions, and work towards a positive ?win-win? resolution. This philosophy and five levels of STEPS (Service, Treatment, Education, Purpose, Success) enable the boys to examine issues of trust, honesty, integrity, leadership, value, clarification, and problem solving.

They are taught the self development by caring and serving others. They help each other with the cleaning and cooking in the house as well as doing many hours of community service. They illustrated this attitude to my colleague, Susan Skelton, and me when we entered the house for the first time and each boy introduced himself to us and asked how he could serve us. This is an amazing change of attitude for some of the boys who were used to being negative and self-serving.

The boys attend school on site. Each boy has an IEP that is designed to help him catch up for failed or missing credits and to continue taking subjects to graduate from high school. The courses are offered through an accredited school in the United States. There is also a lot of experiential education. We took a boat to a neighboring island and enjoyed watching the boys make a presentation on the ecology of the island. They also showed me the mountain they climb and where they go snorkeling for recreation. They will soon add scuba diving to their activities. The boys have very full days from early morning until night. Because of the heat, recreational activities take place in the morning and with the other chores, schoolwork, and community service spaced throughout the remainder of the day. There is a siesta every afternoon. Remember, it?s Mexico!

Family involvement is also a key element to the program. Intensive, weekend family retreat sessions at Kion Bay occur approximately every two months. In addition, modern Internet technology enables parents to see and talk to their son while having a weekly family therapy session. Impressive?. In fact, I would say that Positive Impact had an overall positive impression on me.

I AM NOT IMPRESSED. First of all the boys must clean, cook and do other chores and community service (whatever that is).  The program is designed to help the boys learn "new congnitive thinking and possitive behavior patterns."  It takes 6 to 18 months.  Also the lady was asked by the boys, "how can we serve you?" There's also limited contact with the outside world and parents are only allowed to contact students on-line.  They also have weekly family therapy - which is usually a monitored phone visit with the child.  I saw many RED FLAGS and WARNING SIGNS OF AN ABUSIVE PROGRAM in this flowery post. It's been around since 1999 - there should be more information. It seems like it does have WWASP characteristics.  
The sadist cannot stand the separation of the public and the private; nor can he grant to others the mystery of their personality, the validity of their inner self...in order for him to feel his maximum power, he wants the world to be peopled with concrete manipulatable objects...
-- ERNEST BECKER, The Structure of Evil, 1968.

--- End quote ---

jcb269:
Hi, I have been following this post since i first put it up, and I am not a "troll" as someone suggested it I really do have a brother that is going to Positive Impact.  There has been a lot of beneficial information posted, but my problem is convincing my parents that this Positive Impact poses some potentially mentally abusive charactieristics in its programs.  Does anyone have any suggestions about fomulating an outline a plan to do this?  I just don't know that much about therapy or "behaviour modification" to see red flags.  

Does anyone know a good article talking about the effects of these sorts of therapies.  Preferably not by someone who could be construed as a "radical activist" as my parents would say, but a neutral observer?  Thanks for all the help.

John

Anonymous:
Hello, I myself went to this program, I have been out for 2 years now and would love to answer any questions you have about Positive Impact. Feel free to email me at brianhama@hotmail.com

Anonymous:
My son is attending Positive Impact as a result of his mother's intervention due to drug use in his senior year. He went to 2nd Nature in Utah and followed by this Positive Impact. At 2nd nature, his communication with both his mother and I was very favorable. He confronted with some honesty, his use of drugs and reasons for dropping out of high school.

   I am finding a stone wall in my communications with him via mail or phone. He is in step one and it appears that he will remain there for a time based period as opposed to an achievement based approach. Bottom line is; he wants to leave upon his 18th birthday and his mother and the staff appear to have put up all stops to prevent this from happening. I, as his father, really do appreciate the need for him to confront his issues and own his life. However, some of the tactics that I see, I cannot help but feel are unreasonable. As an example; upon his arrival at PI, he took to reading books. Bear in mind that he had just spent 48 days and nights in the Utah wilderness without a tent and only a tarp over his head. He was ok with that. He even felt a never before sense of inner strength. After 2 days of reading at PI, they put him on a (book blackout). In the days following at one of the sessions, my son mentioned that his 18th birthday was 5 weeks away and that he might choose to leave the program. A matter that is well within his legal rights. The groups response was an intervention that requires him to pay for his meals and rent. Beach time for him consists of wathcing the other boys swim while he picks up trash on the beach to earn his meals and rent. He told me that he is required to ask permission to enter rooms of the house he lives in.
   All of this is to me,- couter intuitive. So far this seems like a bad frat house.
   I await a reply from you, and formost, I'm waiting for a reply from the staff at PI.

An anxious father

PS I would like to take the liberty of posting these questions to you on the wayward web. I will respect the privacy of your response by not sharing it with anyone.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page