AA
Thanks for answering me. Do you feel that programs version of AA is what is going on in church AA meetings, though? I've never seen anyone forced to break down and submit in an AA meeting. It seemed like it was just people sharing their stories, and trying to support one another. Do you think AA works for anybody? I've known people who credit AA with saving their life, that's why I ask. Do you ever feel like you might be sabotaging somebody's recovery by giving them an excuse to go back to drinking? Like, they might say "oh AA is a cult, I knew it! Guess I'll go get drunk!" Do you believe some people have problems with alcohol that they need help, and might not be able to afford a nice rehab center?
I'm asking these in good faith, I'm not looking to turn this into a political battle about AA. I am just curious as how you perceive it, and the people that attend AA meetings. I guess because it's adults who choose to go, and choose to believe in something that works for them, I don't see what the harm is. It's kind of like religion, it seems to help a lot of people, even if it's been bastardized in the past, like you said the 12 steps were, to do harm to some people. I'm wondering, a lot of people believe in God, and religion and the afterlife. What if you were a scientist, and you happened to discover the proof that there is, in fact, no immortal souls, we completely cease to exist at death. Would you offer this proof up, and ruin many people's beliefs that seem to comfort them, or would you keep this information to yourself?
(1) AA is just a watered down version of what the programs push..
(2)When a person arives to the door of any 12 step program they feel they have absolutely no hope. And to be honest cult propaganda can be very persuasive.When they start listening to the propaganda daily for 90 days their mind begins to mess with them, when this occurs they become mindless drones unable to make a decision with out the collective group think
(3)No I don't feel I am sabatoging anybody's said so called sobriety. I am merely helping them see the truth. "They have free choice whether to take the red pill or the blue one..." (Matrix Joke)
(4) You are totally right about it being like religion, hell it is one
CULT defined(1) a system of religious beliefs and ritual; also : its body of adherents
(2) a system for the cure of disease based on dogma set forth by its promulgator
Dogma definedDogma defined1. A doctrine or a corpus of doctrines relating to matters such as morality and faith, set forth in an authoritative manner by a church.
2. An authoritative principle, belief, or statement of ideas or opinion, especially one considered gmato be absolutely true. See Synonyms at doctrine.
3. A principle or belief or a group of them:
Back to topic (5) And yes if I were a scientist and I found there was no existance of creator or omnipotent God, by all means people should be informed.. to hold back information is just is to basically lie, remember in AA if the person has the ability to be honest with himself he too can recover.. True statement... How ever they addopted it I use this line too to help people to wake up from their sleep. As long as a person is plugged into the collective conscious as a group it makes it a hard to make decisions for ones own self... this is a form of independence.
Independence defined(1) The state or quality of being independent; freedom from dependence; exemption from reliance on, or control by, others; self-subsistence or maintenance; direction of one's own affairs without interference.
Max ... I hope this answered most of your questions..
Peace and much healing
:peace: