Jack, try and understand this. We get these horrid stories coming out of the industry at a steady pace. The kind I'm talking about are the ones that any reasonable person would find shocking; unreported rapes, beatings, life threatening privations, unwarranted restraints and all that. Just when you think you've seen it all, another sad tale makes it's way through the filters to the public. They keep on coming consistently over the years and accross even international borders.
Now, you people in the industry seem to take the position that these are anomolies. If you had been in charge, why nothing like that would have happened. But you ignore the circumstances under which these overt, objective abuses occure. You think that, so long as you abide by company policy and don't cross any of those obvious lines that what you're doing is good an helpful. But the same things keep on happening again and again and you seem quite clueless about how that happens.
You might liken what you do to leeching or trepanation or Dr. Hazzard's starvation cure. Once upon a time, well intended practitioners--self appointed experts--would bleed quarts of blood from patients, cut holes in their skulls or just plain out starve them slowly for months, believing that what they were doing was therapy. And I'm sure you think that forcing a personal, rather intimate relationship onto a captive kid is therapeutic too.
Well, sorry, I don't care how many idiots in ties tell you otherwise, those of us who have had the "benefit" of such treatment have found it to be anything but therapeutic. Instead, it's traumatic, humiliating, breaking. And, as an aside, creates firtile ground for all kinds of power based abuses.
So I have no opinion one way or the other about the specific charges against you. But it wouldn't matter. The difference between physical, legally proscribed rape and legal, emotional/psyche rape is pretty nearly irrelavent. Matter of fact, having experienced both, I found the physical rape to be relly sort of a non issue.
Just having sincere and spontanious sympathy and understanding from the very first person I met after the physical rape made all the difference. The mindfuck? That's different. 25 years later and
still, w/ few exceptions, only those who've been through it themselves seem to really understand.
The plans of true believers for our lives may well be better than our own when judged against some abstract official standard, but to deny people their personal struggles is to render existence absurd.
http://www.johntaylorgatto.com/chapters/6n.htm' target='_new'>John Taylor Gatto