I hear ya Mandy,
I know there are a lot of very angry users in this site and I don't blame them, I have my share on this anger too, only I'm not an extremmist and I too believe Elan did some good in my life. Especially considering the fact that I was really messed up before I went to Elan and I don't know what would have happened in my life if I didn't go through that painful experience.
However, it was painful and yes, it was painful because of the concept itself. I exchange e-mails with Tania Merrete on a consistant basis, I'm not ungrateful for all the help that they've given me but I won't forgive them for all the damage that it's caused me either. I won't forgive them, or myself, for missing out on 2 and a half mother fuckin years of my life. Years that were meant to be the best years of my life and no one could possibly give them back to me. I never knew what lonely felt like til I got sent to that place. I never knew what being humilliated felt like til I was sent to that place. Can they give me back that fucking X-mas in which I spent facing the corner of a room begging to come out and being told NO? They can't. In this case, I don't blame myself cause I should have been out of the corner on December 22nd, but since Tania was on vacations, Peter Rowe was running the house and that's the kind of shit he does.
Of course, the same way you believe Jim really put his heart into what he did, I believe there are some really good ppl there with the best intentions in the world. I'm not sure how effective this program is and it's quite difficult to determine it, since the results are presented on an individual basis. It's helped me and damaged me at the same time. It's difficult to put this in perspective since I have so many mixed up feelings about it.
Anyways, this is my opinion based on my experience. I think it's important to respect everyone's opinion, wether they are pro or anti Elan, cause we all have our reasons to feel the way we do. It'd be nice to hear more about your experience, Mandy. And others too. That's why I go to this site.
Peace!
Marina