Well, it's a fine line. If someone attacks you and you don't want to injur them or anything, naturally the responsible thing to do is to restrain them safely till they calm down.
But if the staff and group and parents have antagonized the kid for the purpose of drawing a hostile response, that's entirely different. That's what the Program is essentially all about. They take kids who don't think they need help in changing who they are and keep them under pretty nearly unbearable psychological pressure till they lose their temper. Then they respond to that along the lines of "See there? We told you you were a violent psycho! And just look, you tried to hit somebody! And, after all, we're
only trying to
help you, you ungrateful piece of shit!"
The very basis of the program has a few problems. One, they start out from the premis that the kid has the problem(s) they think they do and then set about convincing them of it. What if they're wrong? What if the kid hasn't got any serious problems, except for over-worried parents? That alone is enough to drive a kid over the edge.
That's an awful lot of power to entrust with anyone, let alone the majority peer staff. Sometimes, the power goes to their heads and they take a sadistic pleasure in inflicting emotional pain on the other clients. (really, when it comes down to it, staff is just another, higher phase in the Program, after all) But there are no witnesses outside of group. And if anyone tries to tell their parents or an outsider when (not if) things go wrong, by rule they're lying, manipulating and subject to a startover.
In a nutshell, there's only one way to make someone change against their will. You have to break their will. Regardless of how worth it some people might think the process is, it's always damaging to begin with.
When he [Califano] claims that the voters of Arizona and California did not know what they were voting for when they supported the two initiatives, he reminds me of the way Serbia's President Slobodan Milosevic reacted to recent election results in that country.
-- George Soros -- Sunday, February 2 1997; Page C01 The Washington Post