1) a commentary is not a justification for or proof of the effectiveness of a program
2) a study showing potential does not mean that is is
3) given the vacuum of proof supporting TBS's and the fact that rights are completely stripped from the people inside who are held captive, incommunicado and with no ability to plead their case, have a day in court or ask for help, but that the apologists of programs cite such bullshit to support their side, I have to refute that.
4) given that there is no proof, after 30+ years of a huge industry existing to support what they do and their methods, I find it amazing anyone even tries to support them.
Only in America do terror detainees have more attention put on them then children who have not committed any crimes.