You have to understand that some (not all) some of these kids sent to these type schools have been given everything under the sun because their parents were financially able to, and because they wanted to be doting parents, but it ended up backfiring because then kids when they become teenagers think they can just do whatever they want and it gets them in trouble and they cant understand why they are being told no. Then, when they get sent to these schools, they think that doing exercises is abuse, they think that cleaning their dorm buildings is abuse, they think that weeding flower beds is abuse, they think that no dessert and cafeteria food is abuse, etc etc etc. No, these schools are no picnic, and yes, there are true abuses that go on in some schools and at the hands of some abusive individuals, and those should be dealt with harshly, but from my experience, the majority of abuse complaints are more along the lines of kids being made to do something they didnt like, not something that truly harmed them physically. But like I said, I know some true abuses do occur, so you would have to take each abuse complaint individually.
******
Yes, this is most of what I am seeing on this website. Complaints that they were kept in rigid line. I too think that the biggest mistake I made was indulging my son for too long. I didn't have a lot of money to spoil him, but after my divorce, I was worried about my children's emotional well-being so if they acted out I would sit them down and talk to them. I thought I was doing something right. And my daughter is fine, but my son has been acting out for some time now and is failing every subject in school and starting to get in trouble with the local police. Some people here have advised that I just let him grow up and keep loving and supporting him. That would be nice if I didn't have a probation officer screaming in my face that he's going to lock him up. So to me it seems that I have the choice of letting the state lock him up, or carefully choosing a place that will give him structure and therapy together.