I have said all along that Hyde needs to figure out who they want to be and then stick to it and advertise accordingly. On one hand they want troubled kids to enroll, and on the other hand they are saying they are a prep school with character education therefore accepting kids who are basically good kids but might need a little motivation.
I hate to say it, but I think they really do want it that way. Either population, by itself, is not going to make the kind of community they want. Each has something to offer the other, and the mix is potentially more than the sum.
Kind of like what Charles Dederich was trying to do with Synanon. He started out in AA, ran into some authority and methodology issues there, so struck out on his own, taking in drug addicts as well as alcoholics. By and by he also started taking in "Straight Gamers," i.e., folks with no history of alcohol or drug problems but who were attracted to the idealism of the community. The mix made for the incredibly vibrant and creative community Synanon was in its heyday.
It didn't last. It depended too much on the vision and charisma of a sole person, a fallible human, as are we all. Control issues developed, and core values were compromised, ultimately taking down the whole shebang.