Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - physics_gal

Pages: [1]
1
Facility Question and Answers / Re: Vantage Point, Utah (Aspiro)
« on: August 29, 2010, 01:58:19 PM »
Thank you guys a whole bunch for your advice (you especially, psy). I'm doing some more research now about the problem of "troubled teen" abuse. I've already studied institutional abuse somewhat; this seems like more of the same, only "justified" because the kids are somehow "bad"... Note the quotation marks, as it seems that the worst these kids were guilty of was being foolish and young and making mistakes. Nobody deserves the kind of treatment I'm hearing about, whether they are disabled, mentally ill, or a "troubled teen"... and the lack of accountability related to taking kids out to the wilderness for "therapy" quite frankly scares me. The potential for abuse seems huge even when intentions are good; and when they aren't... you get tragedy.

2
Facility Question and Answers / Re: Vantage Point, Utah (Aspiro)
« on: August 28, 2010, 07:46:36 PM »
Is there somebody I can PM about this stuff? I don't want them knowing who's making inquiries.

And yeah, I'm well aware there's no proof these programs work. I think that just about any program that doesn't take place in "real life" or do anything to repair the family system is going to be useless for anything other than crisis stabilization. I think residential treatment in general, whether the clients are disabled, mentally ill, or "troubled teens", has too much of a power differential between the staff and the clients to be a useful treatment method beyond the limited (and again, ideally very short-term) application of resolving suicidal crisis or preventing dangerous situations resulting from psychosis.

I did put down "physics gal" for a name, and that's my main focus, but I've studied psychology quite a bit... think of me as a bit of an all-purpose nerd.

3
Facility Question and Answers / Vantage Point, Utah (Aspiro)
« on: August 28, 2010, 04:56:38 PM »
Their web site (remove the spaces):
http: //www. vantagept. org/home

What do you think of this program? Does anyone have experience with it?

The web site is very "positive"-oriented, with lots of talk about how kids will learn "self-efficacy" and stating outright that they don't try to "break" kids.

On the other hand, some really troubling signs...

--Average cost seems to be around $30k, a huge amount of money
--Parent communication is limited; one letter a week, and the kid has to be approved to make phone calls--censoring is very possible
--Some of the activities described include things like hiking... high altitude, long distance; enjoyable for me but I walk a few miles every day for fun; these kids may not be
--They include "primitive living skills" as an activity... red flag for me.
--They accept a wide variety of problems... this inevitably means that the gullible, socially clumsy autistic kid will be in with the charismatic class bully...
--There's no mention of accredited school being available. This is a long-term program; there really should be, or the kids would fall behind academically. The only useful education they seem to get is half a credit of English.
--There are some grammatical and spelling errors on the web page.
--The program seems highly physically demanding; a 10 mile hike mightn't be bad, but three days in a row, with a heavy backpack?... With teens who may very well be unused to walking even one mile, and constantly outdoors? There seems to be potential for abuse here, but whether it's exploited is the question...

I'm asking about this because I want to know whether I should be worried about being associated with this program... I have friends who have been victims of institutional abuse, and have experienced some myself, and do not want to do anything that could possibly make the problem worse.

Thoughts?

Pages: [1]