Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Maximilian

Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 ... 23
31
Quote from: "psy"
Quote from: "DannyB II"
Quote from: "Anne Bonney"
You keep saying that & I keep reading current accounts of programs that are strikingly similar to how Straight operated.

Anne, please stop being stubborn. Try to accept others points of view.
Congrats, you were sopposed to be dead but not, grew up, raised two daughters that had nothing but problems and miraculously did not have to place them in some program.
I would say this has been a great life so far, keep it going.
How was she supposed to be dead and why is it a miracle her kids weren't sent to programs?  You're doing just what many programs do, you're making the presumption that she needed a program, and attempts she makes to defend herself are seen as denial.  this is the sort of fatalistic bullshit that "dead insane in jail" is famous for.  It's a lie.


What if we all accepted that it's true for some kids, and might not be true for other kids. Because that is a fact. The real debate lies with how many kids fall into each category, not whether one group is exclusive of the other entirely.

32
I came very close to dying a couple of times from drug overdose. I've been diagnosed as insane in the hospital before, and I have been in jail. So to some of us this cliche rings true. I can't speak for other people or judge whether they should have been sent to a program or not, for all I know I am the only kid in the universe who really needed to be in the program. But the truth is, I did need it, and without it I would have continued with these behaviors and ended up not insane or in jail, but dead. That's because when you go insane or go to jail, eventually you get out. When I get out I go back to using drugs with a voracious appetite, one that would suggest I don't really value my own life at all. Perhaps that's true, I can't really say and sometimes I do wonder about it, but I believe there is something inside me, something dark, that has never completely disappeared. This darkness prompts me to self destruct, at a rapid pace, and when I get in that state it usually takes an outside force to save me from myself.

So for me it's not a matter of low expectations, it's accepting the inevitable. My most important priority is maintaining some kind of control over this darkness and preventing myself from falling down that rabbit hole once again. I've done fairly well at just that for the past couple of years, and part of that was accepting who I am, and to do that requires an honest examination of myself, despite the depressing conclusions I sometimes reach.  I used to blame the program, and my parents, and whatever else I could to prevent me from having to realize that I was the cause of most of my own problems. I realized it's not the part of me that wants to succeed that causes problems, it's that darkness deep inside that wants nothing but to destroy it's host, like a cancer. When times are good this darkness goes into remission, but it can come like an overwhelming tidal wave, when it's least expected. So to me it's not about low expectations so much as a warning of what could have been, and what might be, if I do lose control again and the darkness takes control over me.

33
Thought Reform / Re: Reversing Operant Conditioning?
« on: September 28, 2010, 12:17:41 PM »
Therapists don't care about you, only the check you hand them after they spend an hour pretending to listen and care about what you told them. Therapists exist because people like to talk about themselves, and are willing to pay someone to sit there and listen to them. It's considered rude to talk to people about yourself for such lengths of time, and friends and family are usually unwilling to sit through such a self indulgence. I'm surprised how much education is required to basically sit there in an office and nod and say, why do you think that is?

I helped get over my own PTSD from the program by finding a local support group of survivors. We meet every week at the local church, and it has done wonders to help me get back to being normal. When I got out of the program I was telling everybody how great it felt to be sober and not have to be the same troubled person I was, but eventually I realized this was brainwashing and so I went back to my old ways of using drugs and not giving a shit about anything, and things have been better ever since.

34
More children die from swimming pool drains than in programs. I'm not saying that a kid dying in a program isn't a big deal, but it's also important to have some perspective. When you are talking about an industry dealing with tens of thousands of kids, a rogue staff might sneak their way into the system and take advantage of it and be mean to kids and physically harm them, or just not do their job and be neglectful and harm them by accident.

Thousands of kids every year die of suicide. That means all of those parents found out their teenager decided to take their own life, many of those parents are the one's who find the dead kid hanging in their closet, or some other gruesome scenario. It's easy to get caught up in how dangerous programs seem on fornits, but there is a lot of other dangers facing troubled teens today, that statistically speaking, are much more dangerous to the well being of a child than being in a treatment program. If your troubled teen is using drugs, and driving around with their friends while intoxicated, what is more likely that they will die in a DUI (accidents in the top 3 leading cause of death of teens, along with suicide) or that they will be killed in the program you send them to? We all know the answer to that, and parents have to make these calculations and it's not a surprise they come down on the side of caution and choose treatment rather than fearing the rare event of program violence, and rightfully fearing the end result of a troubled teen which can commonly be, death , jail or even institutionalization. This is where this statement comes from, it's not a cliche if it's true.

35
Open Free for All / Re: Is fornits better now that it's moderated?
« on: September 28, 2010, 12:00:53 PM »
Quote from: "Ursus"
What was the moderation supposed to accomplish?


My guess would be to bring some credibility to this forum, and make it appear safe to post here to parents, namely those who are thinking of sending their kids away to programs. When you have posters threatening and posting personal details about parents, and making websites about them on porn sites with pictures of the family and everything, it doesn't exactly seem like this is a safe place for parents to come and ask for advice about what to do with their troubled teen.

36
The Troubled Teen Industry / Re: Post your favorite thing about programs
« on: September 27, 2010, 03:36:28 PM »
Please stay on topic. I have received a private message from the admin asking me to stay on topic, and I plan on following that rule from now on. I won't respond to off topic derailments anymore. If you want me to respond Anne, stay on topic, thanks.

37
Quote from: "Anne Bonney"
Quote from: "Maximilian"
If there was a hotline in the program I was at, I would have picked it up and claimed anything and everything in an attempt to get out. I imagine that is why they don't exist, because kids in programs will do anything to get out, including lying about being abused to the operator on the other end of the line. The police or whoever the hotline connected to would disconnect it a couple days after it was activated for this reason, after receiving hundreds of false alarms and prank calls from the kids, I guarantee it.

So, because you would lie that means that all adults who were kids in a program that say they were abused are lying?

Strange way to look at things, but it gives us an insight into your thought process.

The way you extract your own version of what people say from something that doesn't even mention what you are talking about is very interesting. Read my post more carefully and you might understand them better.

38
Open Free for All / Is fornits better now that it's moderated?
« on: September 27, 2010, 03:31:59 PM »
Now that the new version of fornits has existed for a little while, I'm interested to hear opinions on whether you think the introduction of moderation and rules has made fornits better, or worse.

I think it's interesting that so far, the only people who have been banned are anti -program posters.

Do you prefer this new version of fornits, or the older, free for all unmoderated version of fornits?

39
If there was a hotline in the program I was at, I would have picked it up and claimed anything and everything in an attempt to get out. I imagine that is why they don't exist, because kids in programs will do anything to get out, including lying about being abused to the operator on the other end of the line. The police or whoever the hotline connected to would disconnect it a couple days after it was activated for this reason, after receiving hundreds of false alarms and prank calls from the kids, I guarantee it.

40
The Troubled Teen Industry / Re: Dead, insane, or in jail
« on: September 27, 2010, 03:19:23 PM »
Quote from: "Anne Bonney"

These are parents who are being scammed.

Well then, I'm sure they will be pleased to receive an email from you telling them the truth about how they are being scammed. Get to work, go save the innocent kids from getting put in a program by their gullible, naive and ironically wealthy parents. You can do it!

41
The Troubled Teen Industry / Re: Post your favorite thing about programs
« on: September 27, 2010, 03:16:15 PM »
One of my favorite things from the program was getting to meet people from all over the country and learning about different slang words I didn't know about already. I also learned how to play board games I didn't know, and some card games too, and that has come in useful later in life when I needed to play a card game, or board game that I otherwise wouldn't have known how to play. I also learned about weather and astronomy from the teacher in the program, and I liked that a lot.

42
Quote from: "Anne Bonney"
Quote from: "Maximilian"
The demand is there, that is why programs exist.


No doubt the demand is there now.....it's been carefully crafted and marketed by the TTI.  The TTI created the demand.

Imagine you are a single mom, the dad left long ago. You have two sons, and they are both really big, physically. One of them is a good student and doing well, but their older brother is into using drugs, partying every night and getting drunk, not going to school, and when you, the single mother confronts him, he pushes you up against the wall and threatens you. "Don't get in my way, mom, you'll regret it." You are worried that the older son will have a negative influence on the younger son, and you are desperate for help to change this situation. You are lucky enough to have a good job and can afford to send your kid to a program. So you go online, find a reputable Ed Con and begin the process of choosing a program.

This is a typical scenario for a parent seeking out a program. What part of this involves a parent getting scammed, exactly? Parents are extremely grateful programs exist, they don't need to be convinced. In my opinion this claim that parents are all gullible, easily conned people with perfect teens is just totally off base, it does not represent the reality of programs. If you see the industry this way, no wonder it's so confusing to so many of you, because you just don't get it.

43
Quote from: "Shadyacres"
It seems to me that those programs have gotten more abusive, not less.  LIFE was horrible, but they didn't have a hobbit, they never left us in dog cages for a week.  According to you Max, it is apparently impossible to be a bad or irresponsible parent.  This industry is indeed one big con job, jails institutions and death is just one small part of how they convince parents that hating their kids is the best thing for everyone.

If programs did not exist, parents of troubled teens would organize online and end up creating their own. The demand is there, that is why programs exist. According to fornits no parent would think of sending a kid to a behavior program, then a cold calling program marketer calls them and cons them into sending their perfect child away, all to make money. In my own experience this does not come close to accurately describing how this industry is structured. The demand comes from parents, and programs compete to fulfill that demand.

I was put in isolation in the program as you describe, yet I don't consider it abuse. It was clearly explained the rules when we arrived, and if you broke certain rules, like harming yourself in particular you were placed in isolation and staff watched you all the time, because you proved to them you couldn't handle what little freedom you had in the program. There are isolation rooms in psychiatric hospitals, run by the "professionals" and regulated by the state.. They exist for a reason, and as someone who has experienced it I know it's not very pleasant, but that's the point. It motivates you to behave in a way that will prevent you from being placed in it again. That's the essence of behavior modification, and guess what, it usually works.

44
The Troubled Teen Industry / Re: Dead, insane, or in jail
« on: September 27, 2010, 02:52:45 PM »
Quote from: "Anne Bonney"
Quote from: "Maximilian"
Programs exist because parents want them

Parents have been preyed upon by programs and duped into believing that their kids are going to DIE if they don't send them off for re-education and thought reform.

This is an incorrect assessment of the structure of the troubled teen industry. Parents seek the help of programs, and that is why they existed. Programs do not create a false demand, it's already there. That's why there are so many programs open for business. But I know this is all part of the fornits narrative, and I know many people here believe it. But if you talked to people outside fornits, you'd realize this is not true. I suggest you go read forums where parents seeking programs post, and then tell me these are parents who are being scammed.

45
So because people had negative experiences in programs that existed 20-30 years ago, it makes it impossible that newer contemporary programs might offer something those people unfortunately did not receive? For me it's amusing that people who went to programs decades ago telling me that it's impossible I went to a program, or that I was abused but am programmed to say otherwise. As if time stands still in programs, and the experience of those in long shuttered programs of lore, somehow represents the average experience today. Contemporary programs, and wilderness programs exist because parents wants them.

It's not a scam, the parents pay a lot of money because they feel it's needed. To call it a marketing scam, simplifies an entire industry, and ignores so much of the reality of issues facing families dealing with troubled teens. Parents pay good money for programs because they are needed, and for the most part effective. Sure, some bad things happen in  programs. It seems fairly rare that these negative events happen, and judging by the population here on fornits, was more common in programs that existed decades ago. It's time to accept the fact that programs have evolved into an effective and safe option for parents dealing with a troubled teen.

Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 ... 23