Vexing dad, this is really interesting. It really is hard to tell the difference between satire and spontaneous lunacy sometimes. My opinion? Honestly, I'd have to flip a coin. If this is a troll, 10 stars on a scale of 1-5.
If not, all I can say is that you're being absolutely hysterical about the pot and friends. Now it may be true that I was a 17yo escapee from a drug rehab (well, except the part about it being an entirely bogus rehab), but I'm also a mother of three, the eldest being 22. I don't have to hypothesize or conjecture about what I would do in your shoes. I know. I did some things right and some things way, way wrong. First of all, let's talk about the friends. I hated this one chick! Well, hate is too strong a word. But I thought she was petty and shallow and mean spirited. Boy, was I WRONG! Thank God my daughter passed on my advice in that instance. This kid stuck by my daughter through thick and think up to a point far beyond where the rest of her friends lost patience with her.
She lost that friend due to a boyfriend. One girl's bf jumped the other's, there was a mob and gangs and weapons, cops, agrivated assault charges, permanent injury and PTSD symptoms. And my darlin daughter had to choose. I so wish I could turn back time and delete all of those many, many instances when I tried various kinds of prohibition and coercion to try and get this girl to see the little weezle for what he was. Maybe she wouldn't have dug her heels in so hard, maybe things would have been different. As it was, never saw my daughter and hardly spoke with her, except over the phone while Psycho Boy was in jail, from the time of the trial till a couple of years later when she finally decided to take up that bus ticket I had held out for her to come home (follow the family, actually, to another state) Maybe if I hadn't been trying to force my conclusions on her so hard she wouldn't have been fighting me off and she might have reached her final conclusion a good deal more quickly.
But, it's your life, your kid, what the hell do we know?
Do you really think pot smoking is more dangerous than forced indoctrination? Do you really? Well, if so, you're wrong and that's all there is to it. Roughly half of all Americans have been reliably copping to having smoked pot in high school since we started surveying them on the topic in the very early `70's. The vast majority of those I know personally who have significant mental and emotional issues went through the program.
I'm not a fundamentalist prude. When my son's therapist mentioned that most kids experiment with alcohol and/or pot I told her that I wouldn't be that concerned if all he did was smoke a joint on the weekends at a friend's house, but kept up his grades and otherwise held it together. That's not the situation here. Look back at my original post. His first "bad" friend was the one who got him into smoking pot and he got into it heavily. At the time we put him into a short-term inpatient program, his next step would have been dealing pot. We decided to get more concentrated help for him mainly for his underlying emotional problems rather than the drug abuse.
I understand what you're saying about kids wanting to do the opposite of what their parents tell them. I can see his 'contra' attitude even with little things. I even had started using a little reverse psychology on him. However, I can't say, "smoke all the pot you want," or "hang out with drug dealers." In our family group session I noticed the therapist using the Socratic method with him rather than giving him advice or rules to follow. Giving him information and then asking him questions and letting him figure out the answers for himself seems to be the best method to use to teach him.
My wife is determined to use the 'grab the bull by the horns' method. She is adament that he won't return to public school this year. This has been very hard on her because she has a brother who started using pot at an early age and went on to other drugs. He is currently a divorced 35 year old father of 3 and a meth addict. My wife paid his child support payments for two months while he went to a men's Christian Rehab Center. He gave a good speech the day he got out of that rehab saying he was free from drugs. He was using again within a week. My wife has been on our son like white on rice because of her brother's history with drugs. At our family therapy session my son said his mom disgusts him and he kept his hand up to the side of his face so he wouldn't have to look at her. But, she was right about his drug use. She knew the signs.