1
The Ridge Creek School / Hidden Lake Academy / Re: Taylor Hurst
« on: December 08, 2010, 01:35:42 AM »
I knew Taylor.
He was pretty much par for the course, as HLA detainees went. He was pretty much par for the course as OVERALL American high school boys in 1999 went.
He wanted to be liked and admired.. he wanted girls to want to have sex with him.. he was constantly trying balance his own personality with that of his peers, and although he was often callous as a part of this face management strategy, I wouldn't say he was without compassion or empathy.
There was a back and forth here over Taylor's crime and whether it was related to HLA, so, to wit:
1.) First, let me point out that a person's high school experience often informs their self-concept well into adulthood. The average male brain isn't fully developed until age 24.
Taylor was 15 when I met him.
These are formative years, critical for identity development and acquisition of personal morals, and I think we may all do well to pause and consider what effect it may have to spend formative years in an institution such as Hidden Lake Academy, where trust is impossible with peers, the idealized role-models (counselors) abuse power and display dispassion towards their wards, and other examples of adult behavior (restriction staff for example) are people who consistently model sadism.
(Social Learning Theory, anyone??)
2.) A second assertion: Children WERE traumatized at Hidden Lake Academy .
I know of many students with PTSD diagnoses, made by licensed professionals in full accordance with DSM-IV, and explicitly linked to his or her experiences at HLA (myself included).
I won't bother with the defense of this assertion here, as it is well documented under other topics for anyone with opposable thumbs to find.
3.) I would now ask you to consider what you know about PTSD and violence.
Perhaps you recall hearing news coverage of cases wherein soldiers returned home from deployment, only to "snap?"
That is PTSD in action.
Numerous cases exist of these men suddenly murdering their family members. (P.T.S.D.)
If you can't use a search engine, this link is a start:
http://http://ptsdcombat.blogspot.com/2006/12/ptsd-timeline-latest-incidents.html
4.) Taylor Hurst is being tried for his fiancee's murder, and will likely be found quilty. (We all agree on that much, right?)
Right.
...
...
* * * * * * * * * * *
So, to reverse engineer a summation:
* Taylor Hurst murdered his fiancee and unborn son.
* There are numerous cases of uxoricide and filicide being committed by individuals with Post-Traumatic Stress.
* Professionals have determined cases of Post-Traumatic Stress to have a causative relationship with internment at Hidden Lake Academy.
* Taylor Hurst was interred at Hidden Lake Academy for at least two of his formative teenage years.
* * * * * * * * * * *
Correlation is not the same as causation, and so I am not stating that Taylor committed murder as a result of his time at HLA.
I would, HOWEVER, love to see HLA participate in study examining PTSD and the prevalence of violent behavior among its former detainees.
If you are an advocate of Hidden Lake Academy, and keen to challenge any of these assertions, I would first challenge you to lobby for just such research to be conducted (lest you come across as either a pawn of HLA or, worse, a person who would put more effort into protecting an ethically and legally questionable institution than into protecting the children who have been kept there... and those they may grow up to slaughter...).
He was pretty much par for the course, as HLA detainees went. He was pretty much par for the course as OVERALL American high school boys in 1999 went.
He wanted to be liked and admired.. he wanted girls to want to have sex with him.. he was constantly trying balance his own personality with that of his peers, and although he was often callous as a part of this face management strategy, I wouldn't say he was without compassion or empathy.
There was a back and forth here over Taylor's crime and whether it was related to HLA, so, to wit:
1.) First, let me point out that a person's high school experience often informs their self-concept well into adulthood. The average male brain isn't fully developed until age 24.
Taylor was 15 when I met him.
These are formative years, critical for identity development and acquisition of personal morals, and I think we may all do well to pause and consider what effect it may have to spend formative years in an institution such as Hidden Lake Academy, where trust is impossible with peers, the idealized role-models (counselors) abuse power and display dispassion towards their wards, and other examples of adult behavior (restriction staff for example) are people who consistently model sadism.
(Social Learning Theory, anyone??)
2.) A second assertion: Children WERE traumatized at Hidden Lake Academy .
I know of many students with PTSD diagnoses, made by licensed professionals in full accordance with DSM-IV, and explicitly linked to his or her experiences at HLA (myself included).
I won't bother with the defense of this assertion here, as it is well documented under other topics for anyone with opposable thumbs to find.
3.) I would now ask you to consider what you know about PTSD and violence.
Perhaps you recall hearing news coverage of cases wherein soldiers returned home from deployment, only to "snap?"
That is PTSD in action.
Numerous cases exist of these men suddenly murdering their family members. (P.T.S.D.)
If you can't use a search engine, this link is a start:
http://http://ptsdcombat.blogspot.com/2006/12/ptsd-timeline-latest-incidents.html
4.) Taylor Hurst is being tried for his fiancee's murder, and will likely be found quilty. (We all agree on that much, right?)
Right.
...
...
* * * * * * * * * * *
So, to reverse engineer a summation:
* Taylor Hurst murdered his fiancee and unborn son.
* There are numerous cases of uxoricide and filicide being committed by individuals with Post-Traumatic Stress.
* Professionals have determined cases of Post-Traumatic Stress to have a causative relationship with internment at Hidden Lake Academy.
* Taylor Hurst was interred at Hidden Lake Academy for at least two of his formative teenage years.
* * * * * * * * * * *
Correlation is not the same as causation, and so I am not stating that Taylor committed murder as a result of his time at HLA.
I would, HOWEVER, love to see HLA participate in study examining PTSD and the prevalence of violent behavior among its former detainees.
If you are an advocate of Hidden Lake Academy, and keen to challenge any of these assertions, I would first challenge you to lobby for just such research to be conducted (lest you come across as either a pawn of HLA or, worse, a person who would put more effort into protecting an ethically and legally questionable institution than into protecting the children who have been kept there... and those they may grow up to slaughter...).