1
The Troubled Teen Industry / Re: One more thing about the who
« on: May 08, 2010, 12:12:02 AM »
One problem for me is just the word program. It invites the worst connotations.
Unfortunately, my parents could not do a google search to read the pros and cons of a particular program. Today, there are more opportunities for due diligence, but many people still trust "the experts." Many people are still afraid to accept offspring who simply think unconventionally. And youths are so criminalized that no weight is given to their voices when they attempt self advocacy. It is labeled "manipulation." Kids in programs really have no voice or recourse because they are dismissed as troubled, and in fact, programs will often entrench the stigma and heighten the level of familial distrust to unprecedented levels. They look for opportunities to foment distrust because it isolates the kids from the parents, and effectively disempowers both youths and parents.
In a way, programs often dial things up when things don't need to be so dramatized.
I have 3 parents of students who have sent their kids to programs. In two cases, the parents could not accept their child was unconventional. In one case, the parent wanted to "re-educate" their gay child. That one really broke my heart. In all three cases, the parent trusted the program because Jesus was in the mission statement. I can think of a million better ways to "treat" these children - none of them in a program.
We can blame parents all day long but why compound the problem by sending kids to a place that teaches them to label and distrust themselves? You don't have to stand up and say, My Name is Bill and I am an alcoholic to recognize you have a problem. I shouldn't have to adopt other people's values in order to bolster my self esteem and self efficacy. I shouldn't have to adhere to a group treatment when it is has nothing to do with what works for me as an individual. You put a sane person in a loony bin and its no surprise they begin to absorb the environment.
One thing, too, that bothers me about many programs is that the staff become an insular cult clique and lose connection with the outer world. They often become too attached to institutional ideology and apply a very narrow program paradigm to all things and all people.
I do believe that many kids do need help, support, guidance, mentorship, love, and natural consequences. The question is: Can you really get that in a program? There are so many ways to grow and institutionalized growth rings inorganic and untrue to me.
Unfortunately, my parents could not do a google search to read the pros and cons of a particular program. Today, there are more opportunities for due diligence, but many people still trust "the experts." Many people are still afraid to accept offspring who simply think unconventionally. And youths are so criminalized that no weight is given to their voices when they attempt self advocacy. It is labeled "manipulation." Kids in programs really have no voice or recourse because they are dismissed as troubled, and in fact, programs will often entrench the stigma and heighten the level of familial distrust to unprecedented levels. They look for opportunities to foment distrust because it isolates the kids from the parents, and effectively disempowers both youths and parents.
In a way, programs often dial things up when things don't need to be so dramatized.
I have 3 parents of students who have sent their kids to programs. In two cases, the parents could not accept their child was unconventional. In one case, the parent wanted to "re-educate" their gay child. That one really broke my heart. In all three cases, the parent trusted the program because Jesus was in the mission statement. I can think of a million better ways to "treat" these children - none of them in a program.
We can blame parents all day long but why compound the problem by sending kids to a place that teaches them to label and distrust themselves? You don't have to stand up and say, My Name is Bill and I am an alcoholic to recognize you have a problem. I shouldn't have to adopt other people's values in order to bolster my self esteem and self efficacy. I shouldn't have to adhere to a group treatment when it is has nothing to do with what works for me as an individual. You put a sane person in a loony bin and its no surprise they begin to absorb the environment.
One thing, too, that bothers me about many programs is that the staff become an insular cult clique and lose connection with the outer world. They often become too attached to institutional ideology and apply a very narrow program paradigm to all things and all people.
I do believe that many kids do need help, support, guidance, mentorship, love, and natural consequences. The question is: Can you really get that in a program? There are so many ways to grow and institutionalized growth rings inorganic and untrue to me.