Yes, I understand exactly what you mean, and as I've said before, I don't put alot of faith in any state regulatory agency to protect kids myself. It's a near impossibility.
But, when there are allegations against a private corporation, the state can't even do an investigation without going through a bunch of rigamaroll (sp?).
Look at ASR and several others who have refused to cooperate- refused to become licensed and monitored. That's pretty damned arrogant, given that they are absolutely RTCs, take insurance money, money from school districts, the kid is labeled 'disabled' so parents write off visits.
Visits to these programs which are classified as boarding schools with the state. Talk about ODD!!
Society has rules for everyone. Any business that offers services to the public has certain rules they must follow- how they will deliver those services, how they must treat those they 'serve', etc. And, for no other reason, those who are running teen warehouses should also be required to follow certain societal rules, to the extent that this can/will happen. Secondly, it gives more teeth to the state if/when they do take action- which may happen more often with stronger pressure from the public.
I have no pollyanna fantasy that stronger regs is an absolute solution. I think it is a piece of the puzzle. A good interum strategy until collectively, people come to their senses and/or programs realize that they need to treat kids in their 'care' more respectfully. I do believe that some are beginning to realize this as we speak.
And... unfortunately, there is the possibility that absolutely nothing will change. I hope that won't be the case, but it would not surprise me in the least. I am pleased with the passing of this Bill, for whatever great or small difference it might make.
While I appreciate your prediction that the industry will die a natural death in 20-30 years, I'm not so sure. Out-of-home placements have been around for many, many years- religious reform homes, boot camps, military schools- RTCs/Wilderness are just the latest addition, and more appealing to the white middle class. While some may die off over time, I imagine there will always be parents looking to ditch their kid, and an ample number of programs available to supply the demand. And they should technically be subject to some rules of operation.
