Many thanks everyone for your messages. Yes, that really is my Dad, and yes, he was pretty upset about this website. But I think he'll take what you say seriously -- so please, be as honest as you feel you can be.
I should quickly clear up a few things. I guess I was a bit overheated at the time of my first post -- my Dad correctly points out that my bro has been in AARC for about 6, not 8 months. He also says that my brother wasn't forcibly restrained when he entered, but I've got conflicting reports on that one.
In any case, that's me above board.
I'm glad some of you took up his offer, as I believe he's committed to the stance, if not the reality, of being open-minded here. Of course the least productive thing possible would be that two sides just accuse each other of being brainwashed in different ways -- my Dad basically seems to think that having been "druggies" utterly compromises former program participants' capacity to approach this stuff objectively, while I increasingly feel that with him I'm arguing more with an ideology rather than with a person.
Anyway, all that's supposed to encourage is more of the generous honesty you've already displayed. It's appreciated, by me at least, and it might make a difference yet.
Thanks again.
Scott