As far as Parents making life altering decisions for children.. I was just thinking about that tonight.
I never had a drug problem, I didn't do them, wasn't a problem...I did however have some other stuff going on. Abuse at home was the major cause of my running away etc. Subsequently my parents somehow found Straight. (Im sure I dont need to go into proving the program was severley abusive in all aspects) Straight made my life way worse. But I eventually got terminated (Thank God-dess) And tried to pick up a normal 15yr olds life after Straight. School was real hard for me, I was super smart, but I had "been sent away" so I was diffrent. During my 10th grade year, I was expelled from public school for refusing to say the "Pledge of Alligence" Heh, funny now- what I could have done back then, But as Straight proved to me 2 yrs previous, as a teen I HAD NO RIGHTS!.
Anyhow shortly after that expulsion, My Mother wrote me a suicide letter, She was going to kill herself and it WAS ALL MY FAULT AND SHE WANTED ME TO REMEMBER THAT WHEN SHE WAS DEAD. I still have that letter she wrote me(I keep it, so I can know for sure what reality at home was 20 yrs ago) In the letter she Kicked me out of the house, because I had not complied in school, and she was at her end! Pfft, wth were her problems forced on me and blamed all on me... So I packed my stuff at 17yrs old and moved one county away to my Grandparents. (My father's parents whom my Mother hates to this day, but is my only other family) OK, SO I move. My Grandfather took me and tried to enroll me in my SENIOR year of HS, But I had to have the paper signed by my parents... Well my selfish, inable to think Long term Mother refuses to Sign!.... So my only choice was to get my GED, I did.
So here it is 20 yrs later, and I have a GED and Straight Inc on my "record" and all thanks to my Parents... Even though, I am one who didn't have any problems outside my own family's abuse and my trying to run away from it, begging counselors since 6th grade to take me from my parents.
Had my parents not made those 2 horrendous choices, I would have most likely graduted HS, went to college, and built a successful life easily. I look back and clearly see how those choices my parents made, Because they couldn't deal w/ their own issues, left me at a defict for the rest of my life. Yes, I have built an ok life, but it's not been easy. I suffer from a whole host of emotional and thought processing issues (from being abused in Straight Inc, mainly), as well as having trouble gaining further education through the typical means. My parents made my longterm-life very costly.
So I'd like to know, what terrible offense I had done to deserve LIFE LONG trauma from Straight and not being allowed to finish school? I didn't do drugs, I didn't get arrested, I didn't hurt anyone physically, I was not violent.. SO what was it that I did, that won me a LIFE sentence? My parents inability to handle their own lives and then their inability to make clear, positive choices. Thanks Mom, Thanks Dad!
I do feel children should have rights to have a say (or an advocate of sorts in decisions) that will effect and follow them for the rest of their lives. What do kids do that is so horrible that they deserve a life sentence handed down by their parents and these "programs". I'm sorry Parents, I just don't get it. What would your own child have to do to deserve you taking a chance with their LIFE? It could be a great program, but you just never know. I wound up in one of the most abusive in history, all in the name of "My parents just didn't know what to do" That is so sad, imo, Parents have a responsibility to their children to protect them, but so many parents just send their kids off to anyplace that has a pamphlet that says "My program will save your kid!" It sickens me.
I believe, just as in the treatment for PTSD, The key to building up a troubled teens life is GIVING them more control instead of taking away all their control. The severity these programs break these children down is obscene. Why aren't we empowering our teens and teaching them to use their power to suceed? Instead these programs try to INSTIL in the kids, THEY HAVE NO CONTROL/NO POWER/NO RIGHTS and are in custody of the program...Because they were Bad...
The whole deal w/ parents warehousing their kids just makes me ill. And rightly so, I believe after my own personal experience.