OK, back on topic,
The fact is AA is a success, and what makes it a success is the millions of people who participate in it. It's not a top down creation, it is a grass roots community based organization. It exists because people use it, participate in it, and spread the ideas and start their own groups. If it didn't do something, none of these things would happen. So obviously it's doing something that benefits the people who go to this voluntary organization. AA is not books, or steps or anything other than regular people participating in a group that helps them live their lives the way they want to. I'm sure AA can handle the handful of complaints directed at it from this website. You're talking about millions of people all over the world, versus a few anti treatment extremist in the dark corner of the internet seldom viewed. I take comfort in the fact AA is so successful, I believe in it and know it helps people and saves lives. The fact this bothers people says more about them than it does about AA, but haters gonna hate.