Treatment Abuse, Behavior Modification, Thought Reform > News Items
Ranch For Adopted Kids Gone Wild
TheWho:
--- Quote from: "Spew's scrote" ---
As soon as I start saying that these places work, you can ask me what I have. TBSs are the ones claiming success, the burden to prove that falls upon them.
Why are these things so difficult for you to understand?
--- End quote ---
So it seems you cant say they dont work because you dont have any studies... but I have a few:
Academy at Swift River allowed a study to be done by a phd candidate a few years back and then there was Dave Marcus who spent 16 months living at ASR following a peer group through the process and he wrote a book on his experiences there. He won the pulitzer prize for another book he wrote.
Here is a link:
What it takes to pull me through
The woman was a phd candidate from Colgate University and performed an independent study of one of the Therapeutic Boarding schools.
Here is the link for anyone interested in the facts:
http://groups.colgate.edu/cjs/student_papers/2002/VShapiro.pdf
...
Anonymous:
--- Quote from: "TheWho" ---
So it seems you cant say they dont work because you dont have any studies... but I have a few:
--- End quote ---
No, you have no independent, long term, peer reviewed clinical research. Dave Marcus is a paid industry consultant and Shapiro was a grad student. I understand you're intellectually challenged, but surely even you can see the difference.
TheWho:
--- Quote from: "Spew's scrote" ---
--- Quote from: "TheWho" ---
So it seems you cant say they dont work because you dont have any studies... but I have a few:
--- End quote ---
No, you have no independent, long term, peer reviewed clinical research. Dave Marcus is a paid industry consultant and Shapiro was a grad student. I understand you're intellectually challenged, but surely even you can see the difference.
--- End quote ---
Well I hear you but I dont see you posting any proof that TBS's are abusive or ineffective.. you seem to rely on anonymous posts to base your conclusions... do you have any studies to support you conclusions?
Here take a look at what I have:
Academy at Swift River allowed a study to be done by a phd candidate a few years back and then there was Dave Marcus who spent 16 months living at ASR following a peer group through the process and he wrote a book on his experiences there. He won the pulitzer prize for another book he wrote.
Here is a link:
What it takes to pull me through
The woman was a phd candidate from Colgate University and performed an independent study of one of the Therapeutic Boarding schools.
Here is the link for anyone interested in the facts:
http://groups.colgate.edu/cjs/student_papers/2002/VShapiro.pdf
...
Anne Bonney:
Do you think that if you just keep reposting the exact same shit, it will somehow become relevant?
Nihilanthic:
a) A book written by a survivor isn't a study anyway, so that's a misleading statement.
b) The study's outcome was inconclusive, it came down to her opinion that it could be beneficial, but as it was it was not, furthermore, she outlined abusive methods that they used.
c) WHAT positive outcome?
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version