The Salvation Army ARC in San Diego had an almost identical document that residents were required to sign. Llyris Chiles sued them in 1996, and S.A. produced the document in court. The judge asked, "If Mr. Chiles had refused to sign this, would he have been admitted into your program?" They hemmed and hawed around, and finally were forced to answer "no." The judge ruled that the document was coercive, and therefore illegal. She awarded Llyris Chiles $4200. S.A. no longer uses that document.