Yeah, I like Karen too. I'm still not convinced that we need
more regulation, though. I think we need a better educated, less dependent populace.
For one thing, regulation already exists about patient brokering. And, if we're to be honest, what they do to these kids and their families in this industry certainly is some potent psychology. Hardly therapeutic, but potent psychological methods, to be sure. If we could get the existing regulators to see past the imaginary emergency of out of "a generation control" and to
actually hold them accountable for lings like practicing medicine w/o proper licensure, best practices and such, that might help.
For another, really, how smart is it to trust someone to take full custody of your kid, even holding them incommunicado from you and the rest of the world just cause they say they're nice people?? Come
on now, folks!
Third, and most disconcerting, who the hell is A-Start and what sort of solutions do they propose? Last I looked, they seem to advocate
mandatory mental health screening for all school kids. Here's an exceprt cache copy of their conference page:
Title: The Exploitation of Youth and Families by Unregulated Residential Treatment Facilities: A Dangerous Consequence of Unmet Needs
Synopsis: Over the past decade, the number of private residential facilities for U.S. youth has grown exponentially, and many are neither licensed as mental health programs by states, nor accredited by recognized national accrediting organizations. Unregulated residential programs have been linked to reports of youth mistreatment, abuse, and death, as well as exploitation of families. This presentation will provide a description of the phernomenon in terms of common program features and the range of mistreatment reported, including harsh discipline, inappropriate seclusion and restraint, substandard psychotherapeutic interventions conducted by unqualified staff, medical and nutritional neglect, and rights violations. The presenters will then describe the conditions that seem to have facilitated the proliferation of such programs, in terms of unmet need, modern-day marketing strategies, adjunctive service industries including educational consultation and "escort" / transport services, the lack of existent and consistent regulation, and the absence of research. Finally recommendations regarding the coordination of a response to this complex phenomenon will be outlined.
Unmet needs? Wait a second, back up, let's examine this a bit. In my experience and according to a whole lot of other ppl who have been put through it, the majority of kids who land up in these gulags only unmet need is for some sane person to notice that their parents are utterly neurotic and to rescue them from all the unneccessary "help".
And these folks have never answered any questions either about their ignorance of Straight, DFAF and other manifestations of the TOUGHLOVE hategroup right there in their own camp in the Tampa Bay Area over the past 30 years nor about any affiliation w/ the Büsh people's New Freedom Initiative right there on their own campus and their partners, the Bazelon Center for Mental Health Law,
http://www.bazelon.org/ , which seems to be all about garnering ever more
federal funding for mental health services? Shouldn't we screen these people for mental health before we ask them to help improve ours? In my humble opinion, the most dangerous lunatics in the damned country are located right there inside the beltway, except when they winter in Florida.
I'm not saying they're entirely bad. In fact, they give some very good advice and food for thought right here on their fact sheet:
http://cfs.fmhi.usf.edu/projects/AStart ... tsheet.pdfHowever, they are all, except for the victim spokespeople, psyche professionals. Isn't asking them if a kid needs treatment about like asking a barber if you need a haircut? Seriously. Even well intended, well educated, compassionate people have their blind spots.
Keep close to Nature's heart... and break clear away, once in awhile, and climb a mountain or spend a week in the woods. Wash your spirit clean.
-- John Muir
_________________
fka ~ Antigen
Drug war POW
Straight, Sarasota
`80 - `82
return undef() if /coercion/i;
[ This Message was edited by: Eudora on 2006-03-17 23:29 ]