No, it's definitely not the same kid. The Will Sherlund I know was there for his first time. And he was too young to have been in High School back when you were there.
Yeah, what are the odds? But then again, there were two Dave Segal's, 2 Pat Burns', and 2 Julie King's within a few years of each other at BCA. Doesn't surprise me that there were 2 Will Sherlund's.